Hot honey drizzling over a pepperoni grandma pie with fresh basil
Open until 9:30pmDelivery · Pickup · North Babylon

Pizza Night? We’ve Got the Pie.

Dough Made Fresh Every Day, 100% Real Cheese and Nonna’s Sauce, Straight Out of Our Hearth Oven. Order Online and Dinner Is on Its Way.

Nonna's Pizza

9
Nonna's Pizza

Nonna's Pizza

Regular, Upside Down Sicilian, Grandma. Cut to order.

We Use 100% Real Cheese.

Dough Made Fresh Daily.

  • Personal Size Pie4 Slices$13.50A Single-Serving Round, Cut Into Four.
  • Gluten Free Pie 12"$14.50A Twelve Inch Pie on a Gluten Free Crust.
  • Regular Pie 16"$17.50A Sixteen Inch Round With Nonna's Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella.
  • Regular Pie 18"8 Slices$22The Full Eighteen Inch Round, Hand Stretched and Cut Into Eight.
  • Cauliflower Crust 10"$14.50A Ten Inch Pie on a Cauliflower Crust.
  • Upside Down Sicilian Pie8 Slices$23Thick Square Crust Baked in the Pan, Built in Reverse — Mozzarella First, Crushed Tomato Over the Top. Cut Into Eight.
  • Grandma PieSquare$22Thin Crust Pizza With Plum Tomatoes, Roasted Garlic & Mozzarella Cheese
  • Personal Grandma Pie 12"$13The Grandma Pie — Plum Tomatoes, Roasted Garlic, Mozzarella, Romano and Basil — in a Personal Size.
  • Grandma Pie With Vodka Sauce$25The Thin Square Grandma Crust, Finished With Vodka Sauce Instead of Plum Tomato.

Specialty Pie Favorites

12" Personal16" RegularSicilian
  • Hot Honey Grandma Pie12" Personal$15.5016" Regular$31Our Classic Vodka Grandma With Cup & Char Pepperoni Drizzled With Mike's Hot Honey
  • Burrata Fig Pizza12" Personal$2116" Regular$32Sicilian$34Fig Jam, Burrata, White Truffle Oil, Mozzarella, Basil. Add Imported Speck Prosciutto +$5
  • Margherita Pie12" Personal$1716" Regular$27Sicilian$29Plum Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella and Basil.
  • Chicken Penne Alla Vodka12" Personal$17.5016" Regular$31Sicilian$33Penne Pasta and Chicken in Vodka Sauce, Topped With Mozzarella Cheese
  • Spicy Honey Garlic Chicken12" Personal$2316" Regular$31Sicilian$33Honey Garlic Sauce, Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Scallions and Mozzarella, Baked.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza12" Personal$17.5016" Regular$31Sicilian$33Buffalo Chicken and Hot Sauce Over Blue Cheese Dressing With Mozzarella
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch12" Personal$17.5016" Regular$31Sicilian$33Chicken Tossed With Nonna's Ranch Topped With Cheddar Cheese Finished With Bacon
  • Meat Lovers Pie12" Personal$16.5016" Regular$29Sicilian$31Meatballs, Sausage, Pepperoni & Extra Cheese
  • White Pizza12" Personal$16.5016" Regular$28Sicilian$30Seasoned Whole Milk Ricotta & Mozzarella Cheese & Garlic

That’s 9 of Our 38 Specialty Pies. See Every Pie on the Full Menu.

Spend & Get

Order More. Eat Free.

Every Takeout, Delivery and Online Order Over $40 Comes With Free Food. The Bigger the Order, the Bigger the Reward.

Online, Takeout & Delivery OnlyNot Valid for Dine-In

  1. Golden fried mozzarella sticks with a cup of marinaraSpecial 1

    Spend$40+

    Dinner for Two

    Free App

    Roni Flatbread (12), Mozzarella Sticks, Fried Zucchini or a Salad. Your Pick.

    CodeGET40

  2. A whole plain cheese pie in its boxSpecial 2

    Spend$65+

    Family Night

    Free Pie

    A Whole Extra Pie on the House: Regular, Grandma or Sicilian.

    CodeGET65

  3. Chicken parm beside a pile of garlic knotsSpecial 3

    Spend$90+

    Feed the Crew

    Free Chicken Dinner

    Any Chicken Dinner Entrée Plus a Dozen Garlic Knots. The Big One.

    CodeGET90

Online: Add Your Free Item to the Cart and Enter the Code at Checkout. Calling It In or Picking Up at the Counter? Just Say the Code. We Ring It Right In.

Start your order

One reward per order. Can’t be combined with other coupons or specials.

The Nonna Bella's storefront on Deer Park Avenue
Location & Hours

765 Deer Park Avenue,
North Babylon.

(631) 669-1250
  • Mon–Sat11am–9:30pm
  • Sun11am–9pm
Order Direct From Us

Hungry Now?

The oven’s hot. Say the word.

765 Deer Park Avenue, North BabylonMon–Sat 11am–9:30pm · Sun 11am–9pm

Get Our Offers First

Specials and seasonal deals go to our list before they go anywhere else.

Pizza Delivery & Pickup — Nonna Bella's, North Babylon NY